|Too much debt, too little planning
Monday, January 17, 2011
Major credit and debt problems in the United States threw most
of the developed world into a deep recession in 2008-09. Huge
debt loads at the personal, state, and federal levels in the
U.S. have since kept that country from achieving a full economic
recovery and may keep its economy underperforming for the next
decade or longer.
The greenback has struggled, and the U.S. has avoided more
serious problems by printing more and more money to keep things
moving. They can do this only because the U.S. dollar is the
reserve currency for the world. It is used in almost every oil
purchase and is held by most governments in reserve. The fact
that the U.S. economy has been injected with the biggest fiscal
stimulus package in history and still has not fully recovered
gives you an idea of how big the problem really is. It is large
enough to remove America as the “economy that moved the world.”
The Canadian connection
Many people will ask how the U.S. debt and related economic
problems affect Canada, which for the most part came through
the recession much better than our southern neighbors. In its
Dec. 14, 2010, issue, The Vancouver Sun pointed out, “Canadian
household debt as a percentage of disposable income is now higher
than the US levels for the first time since 1998.” That’s a
Whatever you may have planned for the future, it will be more
difficult to achieve with higher debt. Being aware of debt and
making it a fiscal priority to reduce debt over time is a cornerstone
in the financial planning process.
By some estimates, Canadians are retiring with more debt now
than ever before. That is another red flag. When a couple is
moving towards retirement, getting that mortgage and other debt
paid off is just as critical as saving money in pensions, RRSPs,
non-registered savings, and TFSAs. Going into retirement with
no debt helps you in many ways. There’s less stress in retirement
(if interest rates rise), you are able to live on less capital,
and you are less dependent on stock markets, because you you
can live more cheaply.
With North American debt at very high levels, what happens
if interest rates rise? Higher debt-servicing costs and a slower
economy as a result of consumers’ reduced purchasing power.
Your standard of living will also decrease unless you also have
corresponding increases in salary to offset higher debt-servicing
costs. We have had historically low interest rates for quite
some time. It’s worth noting that nothing lasts forever. Low
interest rates won’t either. In the short to mid-term, rates
need to stay low to help the anemic U.S. economic recovery to
Consumption, credit and debt
Our developed economy is very good (maybe too good) at getting
credit in the hands of consumers who aren’t afraid to use it.
Many credit card companies bump up your credit limit (often
without informing you) after you achieve a decent payment history
with the company. That is a very dangerous practice (for consumers).
Before you know it, you have $20,000 or $30,000 credit available.
The credit card companies make the most money from people who
don’t pay the full amount every month. They like clients who
pay the minimum, because they make a fortune off you in interest
charges. If you can’t pay the full amount off in most months,
it is a signal that you are living above your means. This can
and will catch up with you. I contacted my credit card providers
and requested that they don’t increase my credit without my
At least once a year everybody needs to do a quick net worth
calculation. Add all assets, like your home/condo/vacation property,
RRSPs, and investments, and subtract mortgage loans, lines of
credit, credit card debt, car loans, and any other debt. That
gives you an idea of your net worth.
Under normal circumstances, your net worth should grow. If
markets drop 30% to 40% as they did in 2008, growth in your
net worth is likely to stall, but situations like that are an
anomaly and beyond your control. Even if your net worth is increasing
over time, your liabilities (debt) should decrease. You don’t
want a big mortgage heading into retirement, because that will
surely curtail your retirement lifestyle unless you have very
high cash flow.
When are we fiscally on track?
We are bombarded by offers and advertising on a daily basis,
but buying too much of what we want as opposed to what we need
can get us into serious trouble, even if we’re paying everything
off each month. I think you are on track when the following
items are taken care of:
• Your net worth is rising over time.
• Your overall debt is decreasing over time.
• You are investing regularly in RRSPs (to reduce taxes and
save for retirement), especially if you don’t have a defined
benefit pension plan.
• You also invest in TFSAs, non-registered accounts, and RESPs
to take advantage of government programs to save tax or receive
grant money for education
• You have adequate life and disability insurance.
• You have some short-term savings (in case of job loss, to
pay for holidays, emergencies, etc.).
• You have wills in order.
My dad always says “stress is a killer.” Well, debt can be
a killer too. Not in the same way as my dad meant, but it can
be a killer of dreams and plans. If you play too much today
and accumulate too much “stuff,” instead of putting away 5%
to 10% to “pay yourself first,” you’ll probably be forced to
work long into retirement. And that’s the real consequence of
too much debt and too little planning.
Generic Mutual Fund Disclaimer
Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees and expenses
all may be associated with mutual fund investments. Please read the
simplified prospectus before investing. Mutual funds are not
guaranteed and are not covered by the Canada Deposit Insurance
Corporation or by any other government deposit insurer. There can be
no assurances that the fund will be able to maintain its net asset
value per security at a constant amount or that the full amount of
your investment in the fund will be returned to you. Fund values
change frequently and past performance may not be repeated.
Personal Opinions & Recommendations Disclaimer
The foregoing is for general information purposes only and is the
opinion of the writer. This information is not intended to provide
specific personalized advice including, without limitation,
investment, financial, legal, accounting or tax advice. However,
please call the author to discuss your particular circumstances.